It’s Over!!! NO LONGER A RUMOR😭This is what happened to Ethan & Teegan after the show ended
The whirlwind romance between Ethan Plath and his “second chance at love,” Teegan Nichols, has reportedly imploded in a mess of social media deletions and shocking cheating allegations.
When Season 7 of Welcome to Plathville premiered, Ethan was gushing to the cameras about finding “the one” for the second time. After his brutal divorce from Olivia, fans were happy to see him with Teegan, a mother who seemed to fit perfectly into the Plath family’s more traditional lifestyle. However, by August 2025, the “absence of drama” Ethan once bragged about has turned into a total production nightmare.
The Instagram “Scrub” Heard ‘Round the World
Fans first suspected trouble when Ethan—who famously deletes all traces of his exes—suddenly wiped his Instagram clean of every photo featuring Teegan. Shortly after, Teegan unfollowed Ethan and removed their “couple goals” posts. While she notably still follows Ethan’s siblings like Isaac and Moriah, she has completely iced out Ethan.
The “Best Friend” Scandal
The most explosive detail emerging from the split is the reason behind it. Multiple insiders and fan reports allege that Teegan caught Ethan cheating with her own best friend. The betrayal reportedly happened shortly after filming for Season 7 wrapped, leaving Teegan devastated. Fans have pointed out the irony: Ethan often criticized Olivia for her “lack of loyalty,” yet he is now facing accusations of the ultimate betrayal.
The Ghost of Olivia Plath
Compounding the drama, reports suggest that Teegan became uncomfortable after learning the full extent of Ethan’s ongoing divorce battle with Olivia. Rumors swirled that Ethan hadn’t been entirely honest about how “finalized” the divorce was, leading Teegan to feel like she was a “rebound” caught in a legal crossfire.
Where They Stand Today
Ethan has retreated to his cars and the safety of the Plath family farm in Georgia, while Teegan is focusing on her child and moving on from the reality TV spotlight. It seems the “sweet and patient” girlfriend Ethan introduced to the world finally ran out of patience.